Why Jorginho deserves the Ballon d’Or more than Messi

by | Oct 14, 2021 14:39

With the 30 nominees for the Ballon d’Or announced, Nima Tavallaey Roodsari looks to the five reasons why Jorginho should be named the best player of 2021.

When the shortlist for this year’s Ballon d’Or nominees was unveiled last week, many fans were, quite rightly, shocked and appalled that Federico Chiesa’s name was left out. However, even if the Juventus and Italy winger had been included in the 30-man list, he is still far from deserving to be in the top 3, let alone win it.

Instead, the accolade as the best player of the year in the world belongs to Chiesa’s Azzurri teammate, Chelsea’s Jorginho. Below are 5 reasons why the former Napoli midfielder deserves to win the Ballon d’Or.

1) Integral part of Chelsea’s Champions League winning side

Jorginho not only started 12 out of Chelsea’s 13 matches en route to winning the club’s second title in Europe’s premier club competition but also captained the side twice along the way.

He only failed to make it a lucky number 13 out of 13 matches played. That’s because he was suspended in the return leg of the Round of 16 against Atletico Madrid due to accumulating too many bookings.

But aside from that one game, he never missed a start and never played less than 65 minutes.

In fact, he played the full 90 minutes in all of the knockout matches he started, being subbed off late three times in the group stages. In both clashes with Sevilla, the second time in the 85th minute when the game was already won, and against Krasnodar, after 71 minutes.

No other outfield Chelsea player racked up more minutes than the Brazil-born Italian midfield Maestro en route to lifting the cup with the big ears, second only to goalkeeper Edouard Mendy, and both men playing just over 1,000 minutes.

2) Italy would never have won Euro 2020 without Jorginho

The same pattern is repeated when looking at his importance to Roberto Mancini’s Italy when winning the European Championships this past summer.

Jorginho was once again the outfield player with the most minutes on the pitch in the entire competition, starting all of Italy’s seven matches, being subbed off only once after 75 minutes against Wales in the meaningless final group stage match. The latter is significant as Roberto Mancini rotated the team heavily, with the group already won.

Everyone could be rotated, except for Donnarumma and the indispensable Jorginho, who covered the most distance out of all the outfield players at UEFA Euro 2020, including England’s Kalvin Phillips, who came in second. The former Hellas Verona midfielder recorded a stunning 93% passing accuracy and completed 497 passes throughout the tournament, the most of any midfielder, second overall to Spain defender Laporte. 

3) The bias in favour of goalscorers and assist-providers must end

The result of a football match is, of course, ultimately measured in which teams score the most goals. And it is only natural that the game’s low-scoring nature allows the goalscorers to retain most of the limelight. However, it is reductive and archaic always only to measure who the best player is along with those parameters.

This is particularly true when considering the importance of goalkeepers and central defenders to title-winning teams at both club and international level. And it should be extended to non-scoring and assist-providing midfielders as well, such as Jorginho, who has demonstrably offered invaluable quality leading to trophies.

Jorginho is the brain behind the build-up play, which inevitably finds the spaces and the players movements, which lead to assists and goals. The secondary assist if one speaks ice hockey. He is the beating heart that dictates the tempo with which his teams dominate their opponents. Defensively, the Chelsea man is a reference point for his teammates when interpreting their positional roles on the pitch.

And no more so did it become evident than this last year at both Chelsea (especially after Thomas Tuchel took over) as well as with Italy in the European Championship.

4) No Italian midfielder has won it since Gianni Rivera in 1969

When Roberto Baggio won it in at Juventus in1993, the Divine Ponytail had completed his positional shift up the pitch as a forward, so he doesn’t qualify as a midfielder. By the time Milan legend Gianni Rivera won the award, he’d played in every single position in midfield, from regista to mezzala to trequartista.

Since then, no Italian midfielder has won it, not even Andrea Pirlo in 2006, when Fabio Cannavaro prevailed. The Ballon d’Or was awarded in 1969 to Gianni Rivera for helping his beloved Milan win the European Cup/Champions League. In 1993 it was given to Roberto Baggio for outstanding performances leading his Juventus to glory in the UEFA Cup.

Fabio Cannavaro got the accolade for bringing glory to the Azzurri in 2006 at the FIFA World Cup in Germany. Nothing for Franco Baresi, Gigi Buffon, Paolo Maldini, Alessandro Del Piero, Pirlo or Francesco Totti before or since.

In 2021, Jorginho was the most crucial player for Italy and Chelsea when winning the European Championships and the Champions League respectively, equalling the achievements of the legends above but doing so in one season. Jorginho is not a better player than Roberto Baggio or Gianni Rivera, but comparisons help when contextualizing accomplishments.

5) No other player deserves to win The Ballon D’Or – especially Lionel Messi

Allow me to elaborate before I drown in a cacophony of outrage from the Messi fanboys online army.

I subscribe to the notion that awards are based on the merit of achievements, not on appreciation of talent. Lionel Messi achieved nothing in the last 12 months that remotely eclipses what Jorginho achieved during the same period. Unless you think finishing third in La Liga is a far more remarkable feat than winning the Champions League.

Or winning a tournament where eight out of 10 teams from the group stage make it to the quarter-finals, as was the case in Copa America, is far more impressive than winning EURO 2020 after defeating Belgium and Spain en-route to beating England at a packed Wembley.

Verratti Jorginho Italy

5 Comments

  1. Michael

    Agree with all points except 4: how long ago another Italian midfielder won it is irrelevant to whether Jorginho should win it. All that matters is who’s the best candidate this year.

  2. Serie a legend

    if Luka Modric won why the heck not??????

  3. a Varsavia

    Stop joking, Robert Lewandowski (FC Bayern) is better than this two combined.

  4. geedup

    Wow these are some really weak reasons.

    You can come up with a bunch of different arbitrary reasons to justify why any player deserves the Ballon d’Or. It can’t be solely based on being a part of the winners of both major competitions this year, otherwise Christian Karembeu and Roberto Carlos should have won in 1998 and 2002 respectively. What makes Jorginho exceptional to deserve it? He was integral to Chelsea – so was Havertz, Mount and Azpilicueta. Italy would never have won without him – same can be said about Donnarumma, Chiellini in the latter stages or even Bonucci.

    To claim Jorginho is more deserving than Messi because of the Copa America format is a strawman argument and the same superiority mentality from UEFA football elitists. Argentina won their group so saying 8 out of 10 teams from the group stages get to quarters is irrelevant. They played 7 different teams in the tournament (same as Italy) and Messi was also the best player and top scorer – Jorginho won no individual award. I’d argue Messi deserves it more than Jorginho on that basis and I’m no Messi fanboy because I don’t think Messi deserves it either. The other points are subjective and should not even be considered as valid reasons.

    I agree with a Varsavia, Lewandowski, while only winning a league title, has been head and shoulders better than any other player this year. The only reason why Jorginho’s name is even being mentioned so much is because he plays in the PL. We all know they love to market their brand, which includes their players, so Jorginho winning it promotes their brand. If England had won the Euros, they wouldn’t even consider winning the PL or UCL as a factor (seeing as Mount wasn’t integral in their Euro squad), they’d be hyping Kane using reasons like he also won the PL golden boot and he’s the England captain and so on.

    Let’s be real, the Balon d’Or is a popularity contest voted by media reps, national team coaches and captains. I doubt many of them would even consider Jorginho. It’s likely the Copa America win will tip it in Messi’s favour. I mean he undeservingly won it ahead of Iniesta and Xavi in 2010 and 2012 even though they won the WC and Euros while he only won a domestic title so I’d be amazed if he was now overlooked after finally winning an international tournament with his country even though he won nothing at club level.

  5. Prasanna

    All of the points are fair enough but doesn’t give Jorginho a solid backup.
    1 – Jorginho being intergal part of chelsea CL triumph – Of course but the stand out performers in Chelsea squad were Kante, Mason Mount & havertz.
    2 – Euro 2020- Standout players were Chiesa, Spinnazola and Insigne. How many goals Jorginho scored or How many he assisted< or how many big chances he created? Despite Copa is less competetive than Euro, Argentina had mediocre team and Messi was superior in all of the areas, Goals/Assists/Big chances Created and finally he won though.
    3. How did Jorgino performed in League? Goals/Assists ? Messi was liga top scorer again and won Copa Del ray.
    4. Lets compare Play making in 2020 against Jorgino & Messi. Those who say Jorgino pulled the strings better, they must be blind.

    So Messi deserves more than anyone else. The only one who comes closer is not Jorginho but its Lewy.

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

 NEWS

RELATED POSTS
Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap